Monica Graff wins for her essay The Doubts at the Door. Congratulations Ian!
This is what the judges had to say about Monica's submission:
"Talking to your characters or your fears is a fairly common idea, but this version is very nicely done. It's well written and gets the concept across in a piece that actually has a beginning, middle and end."
For all the humour writers out there, here're some general comments from our judges to nail that humour:
"1. Remember to write a great opening paragraph that is also funny so that the reader is not only engaged, she is clear of the tone of the piece.
2. With comedy, make sure to close with a big laugh.
3. Keep in mind some of the basic rules of comedy to boost the funny. For example, the K Rule, the list of three, comparison jokes and definition jokes."
Here's the winning piece:
I leaned against the door frame and stared at the ceiling until their footsteps faded. “Sheesh,” I whispered. “I’ve got to quit eating onions before bedtime. They give me the strangest dreams.”
About the author:
Monica Graff spent two decades editing scholarly monographs for university presses before she decided to put down the red pen and pick up the black one. Now she explores the world with her husband and blogs about it on "Postcards from Polebridge." In December she's returning to school, to earn an MFA in Creative Nonfiction at the Vermont College of Fine Arts, which she finds both terrifying and exciting.
Winner of the Verbolatry Laugh-a-Riot Contest 2016 PAID category announced!
Ian Tucker wins for his essay Pride in Creation. Congratulations Ian!
This is what the judges had to say about Ian's submission:
"Nicely sarcastic. Dryly amusing but that's right for this piece."
"This is definitely the gem of the collection. The writer expresses angst and frustration that we have surely all felt with all the conflicting "advice" out there - and in this case does it in a fashion that elevates an experience we have all shared to a statement that is unique to this writer. And I really wanted to read that vampire/puffin story!"
For all the humour writers out there, here're some general comments from our judges to nail that humour:
"1. Remember to write a great opening paragraph that is also funny so that the reader is not only engaged, she is clear of the tone of the piece.
2. With comedy, make sure to close with a big laugh.
3. Keep in mind some of the basic rules of comedy to boost the funny. For example, the K Rule, the list of three, comparison jokes and definition jokes."
Here's the winning piece:
Pride in Creation
by Ian Tucker
I write a short story. Pride propels me to enter a competition. I discover I have done wrong. Like the unwary dresser with an unaccustomed jumper, or a horse struggling behind its cart, things have gotten back to front.
Competitions, it turns out, have rules. Apparently, I should have read them.
But that is not all. There are themes and back issues and styles. There are judges who have read the masters of the art and who have tastes and preferences to respect and reflect.
Unfortunately, a few background checks indicate that the judges will probably recognise pap. There is a distinct possibility my story is pap.
I reassess whether I was right to ignore the "local writer's group" because of the apostrophe in their advert. I regret finding the Tilebury Short Story Anthology (#7) boring. I wish I'd got around to understanding metaphor and allegory.
Maybe I should have tried to emulate a famous short-story-wright? I dredge memories for names like Stephen King, Poe, Ray Bradbury and that bloke who wrote about Tobermory the cat. I can't, however, recall any living specialists. I begin to doubt I am embodying the zeitgeist. Like the little piggy who built his house on sand, I sense adverse winds and worry about my foundations.
I do some belated research. I giggle on discovering how much advice I've ignored.
Apparently I should have read widely, written daily, attended book-fairs, obtained a mentor and had a lifelong determination to work in publishing. I should have done an arts degree and shown. I should not have told. Importantly, I should not have an MA in creative writing because that corrupts creativity. I learn that creativity is all important provided it is presented in a standard font. Also, Stephen King is still alive.
I am intimidated and marbled with doubt.
I revisit my story. A critic might criticise. It is not obvious that I have spoken powerful truths lightly. I have also, arguably, not plumbed the truth of contemporary hypocrisy without using adverbs. A vampire who turns into a puffin rather than a bat no longer seems quite so inspired as the story's core. I should, perhaps, have chosen a weightier topic. Like loss perhaps, or heartbreak or chocolate.
And I should have killed my darlings.
This is where I rebel. I like my darlings. My darlings were mostly the reason I wrote the story. If competition credibility requires their sacrifice, I choose not to compete. It is a matter of principle. I feel better and morally impregnable.
Even though my story would undoubtedly have won, I decide to keep it to myself. In three months I'll pretend to edit it so I can secretly laugh at my own jokes. No one will know. Oh god! All that effort and no one will ever know.
But at least I didn't do an MA in creative writing. I have that to cling to.
About the author:
Ian writes for entertainment and his own amusement. He tries to write crime, fantastic fables for adult dreamers and horror although most of his stories are at least tinged with farce. His website www.tilebury.com is populated with a decade of light relief from his day job and a good deal of dry humour. He's also rather fond of cartoons and wishes he could draw.
Judging for our very first writing-related humour contest is now complete.
The wait is nearly over. Our awesome judges have given their verdict and the scores have been tallied. Thank you to everyone who participated, whether as an entrant, promoter, sponsor or judge. You're fabulous. Your interest means there's hope and encouragement out there for writers and artists to continue creating good works in good humour!
For a new unestablished contest of this niche, we were delighted with its reach and volume.We received a total of 80 entries. It was fun reading them and many made us chuckle! Of those that qualified, the following is the shortlist in alphabetic order of title:
Category: FREE
Buttering-Up Can Leave Egg On Your Face by Dina Leacock
Literary Evening Turns Bad by Angela Wright
Stream of Consciousness Nonsense by Janice Abel
The Cat-A-List by Anthony Wobbe
The Doubts at the Door by Monica Graff
The Front Line of Writing by Emily Wood
Writers Who Read by Ernad Osmic
Category: PAID
Being a Writer by John Dilworth
New Balls, Please! by Rosemary Hillyard
Press Play by Marjorie Sato-Bukowski
Pride in Creation by Ian Tucker ... and a special mention to Geek Muses by Carmen Welsh for being the only cartoon submitted.
Congratulations to the shortlisters and well done! Your work was cream of the crop and it was a close fight to the finish.
We know you're eagerly awaiting the results, so sit tight, stay tuned and watch this space. If you're a Verbolatry subscriber, our newsletter issues next month will announce the winners and present the winning entries. You can subscribe here.
Let the party begin!
Send us your funnies about writing and win cash prizes!
Judges
They say a contest is only as good as its judges. By that account, we rock! For our debut year, we've managed to bag ourselves three terrific titans of the writing industry:ably assisted by your humble servant Devyani Borade and her alter-ego Debora!
Read more about the judges.
Sponsors
Explore their offerings to see how you can benefit.
|
Contest Rules
Category: FREE
Tell us where you heard about this contest (Our charismatic promoters)
Last date: 31 August 2016 THIS CONTEST IS NOW CLOSED.
Category: PAID
Tell us where you heard about this contest (Our charismatic promoters)
Last date: 31 August 2016 THIS CONTEST IS NOW CLOSED.
- You will be subscribed to the newsletter when you participate in the contest, although you can unsubscribe at any time.
- By entering the contest, you guarantee that you are the author of the work.
- Winners will be contacted via email.
- If your entry wins or is shortlisted, you grant us first electronic rights and non-exclusive electronic archival rights. Winning and shortlisted entries will be published on the Verbolatry website and in the Verbolatry newsletter, which is then archived in its entirety.
- There is only one prize for each category regardless of the type of entry submitted.
- Payment of the prize will be made within 30 days of publication.
- If multiple entries are submitted by a single author in the FREE category, only the first will be accepted.
- Entries sent by post will be discarded without consideration.
- Entries that don't follow these rules will be discarded without consideration.
- Entry fee is non-refundable.
- If your piece gets accepted for publication elsewhere, you must inform us promptly so that we can withdraw it from consideration.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
If you're associated in any way with this industry, we bet you have a funny story to share!
How can you compare cartoons with essays?
What are the judging criteria?
How long will the shortlist be?
No less than five and no more than eight entries, per category.
What happens if there's a tie?
To be announced.
* Why do early birds get a benefit?
For balance of volume. Contests get many last-minute entries. If we get a flood of late submissions, we may get overwhelmed and results may be delayed. That would make us cranky. So we encourage early submissions to maintain a nice steady flow of entries. Seriously, you don't want to make us cranky. It's not pretty.
Hey, wait. I know you people. We're friends. We chat often. Do I get the inside track on the contest? *nudge* *wink*
We're friends, you say? Well, don't worry, we won't hold that against you! On the other hand, it won't earn you any favours either.
Yes! All are welcome, as long as they can meet the requirements above. Competition is fierce. You are pitting your work against strong contenders, many of whom have years of experience in the industry. So make sure you bring your A-game. (Hang on, you really live at the science stations on Antarctica? Cool, please spread the word there, too. Unless you're a penguin.)
Can I collaborate with a friend and submit a joint entry?
No. Each entry must have only one author.
Can I enter a poem/novel excerpt/screen play/photograph/podcast/anything other than cartoon or essay?
Sorry, no.
Will my entry be acknowledged?
In a way. You will be subscribed to the newsletter, which is emailed twice a month. So if you've received an issue of the newsletter, we've received your entry to the contest. If you don't receive an issue within a month of sending your entry, please contact us.
Why are you subscribing me to your newsletter?
What if I am already a subscriber?
Then we love you, and you rise to the top of our favourite persons' list. Fear not, you won't be signed up twice, but you also won't get any preferential treatment as far as this contest goes. Perhaps we can schmooze over a coffee later? Sucks, we know, but we're painfully unbiased here.
What do you mean by 'previously unpublished'? Does my blog post/facebook update/twitter tweet count?
Afraid not. If it's been published in a blog, book, magazine, website, anthology, CD, chat room, writers' forum or even critique group, it does not qualify. If it's still in your little black diary at home buried under clothes and last night's dinner in a corner of your desk drawer, and nobody other than your mum has set eyes on it, it's probably okay to submit.
Why aren't you accepting reprints? Won't that increase your subscriber numbers?
It will. However, we want this contest to be a level playing field for everyone. We want to encourage you to create something brand new! The contest focus is broad enough to allow plenty of latitude for ideas, yet narrow enough to direct and channel your creativity. If your work has been previously published five times, or fifteen, it's probably good, and you should be proud. Now let's give everyone a chance to shine.
I found I made a mistake in my entry, but I've already submitted it. Can I send in a correction, revision or updated version?
No. All submissions are final.
If your entry gets shortlisted or wins, we ask for publication rights as above. If your entry doesn't make the cut this time, then nothing, you can treat it as before. You don't lose any rights.
Do you accept cheques or direct bank funds transfers?
I love your FAQs! Can I copy them and use them on my website/competition?
We're flattered, but no, thanks. In fact, why settle for imitation when you can get the real thing? Hire us and we'll manage your contest or write copy for you which is as scintillating or even better. Our rates are very modest. In fact, they are so shy and retiring, you'll have to contact us to get a peek at them. Go on, we'll wait.
Still have a question we've not already answered? Feel free to ask us at v3rbolatry(at)gmail(dot)com.
Our business address is:
Hohenstaufenstraße 2 | Düsseldorf | 40547 | Germany
Puzzled... The announcement of the contest the states the the prize is £100. Yet, under the Contest Rules it states that the prize is £50. Which is correct?
ReplyDeleteDear Sandra R,
ReplyDeleteThe prize in the free category is £50. The prize in the paid category is £100. Therefore, an entrant can potentially win a total of £150 altogether. I've clarified that in the side bar announcement now. I hope you will consider participating!
Best wishes,
Devyani Borade
Hi Devyani,
ReplyDeleteOne more clarification needed--can the same essay be submitted to both the free and paid contest or are you looking for two different pieces? Thanks for your help!
Karen
Dear Karen Ray,
ReplyDeleteDifferent pieces, please! We'd like it to be challenging and fun for you as well as our readers! Thanks!
Best,
Devyani Borade
To all you latecomers who're cutting it too close to the deadline: Just a heads up as we go into the final weeks of the contest. We have received very few entries in the PAID category so far, so if you take a chance with a fiver or tenner, you could scoop up a neat little profit of £90-£95 if you win. Not bad for the price of an icecream tub!
ReplyDeleteI found this comp online and like it. Do you accept PDF, or Word format?
ReplyDeleteAndy
Dear Andy,
ReplyDeleteNeither. Essays must be submitted pasted into the body of an email message as plain text.
Best wishes,
Devyani
Folks, an entry may be either a cartoon or an essay (prose, e.g. traditional essays, short stories, vignettes, memoirs, etc.)
ReplyDelete